« Brooklyn: A Quickie Film Review | Main | Jury Duty: Rejection and Cooties »

30 December 2015


Nancy Myron

Sue, thanks for the review. You put your finger on something that disquieted me when I saw the film. I went to see it with 6 other Lez-Fems. We were all in a festive mood about seeing the film. When we came out we all had a brief discussion on the sidewalk and then departed. My one criticism was the way they kissed. I couldnt help thinking of the Madeleine Kahn line from Young Frankenstein,"No tongues!" You're right that it lacked that wonderful emotional fire and electricity that I have felt when watching films that have.lesbian romance. Films like Desert Hearts, Les Bische(sp.), The Killing of Sister George and more recently, A Room In Dome. Thanks for your insights.

sue katz

Nancy, thanks for writing. I saw it with a bunch of dykes as well and we all left deflated. But I never heard of "A Room in Dome," so thanks for that - something to live for.

Nancy Myron

Sorry Katz, its A Room In Rome


How interesting! I have read several rave reviews, and a dyke friend was blown away by it just the other day. I have yet to see it, so I'll reserve judgement, but the dynamic is troubling; when I read your description of Therese above I was forcefully reminded of The Killing of Sister George -- and not in a good way.

On the other hand, watching the trailer I was struck by Rooney Mara's resemblance to Audrey Hepburn. In a GOOD way.

Thanks as ever for your insights, Katz.

sue katz

Thanks for your thoughtful comments, Marj, and Happy New Year.


Thanks for your thoughtful review. I think I'll save my money for something more exciting!

sue katz

Steph, a lot of women really loved the film, so don't reject it only on the basis of my reaction!


I've heard other women have similar reviews of "Carol" - those whose opinions I generally agree with on things of this nature. And, I've had the feeling I won't like it anyhow. Movies are too expensive and my time too precious to spend recklessly. Thanks again for the review.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

Your email address:

Powered by FeedBlitz

Blog powered by Typepad